This evening at my daughter’s track meet, the event dutifully began with our national anthem “The Star Spangled Banner.” While the tune is a rousing and patriotic one, I have always wished that our national anthem was “America the Beautiful.” And tonight, as I thought about the lyrics to each of these paeans to the American way, I realized why.
“The Star Spangled Banner” is a song of victory in war. So many of the images, especially beyond the famous first verse, speak of destruction and conflict: “rockets red glare,” “o’er the ramparts, “bombs bursting in air,” “the havoc of war.” It is a song that first and foremost glorifies the vanquishing of our enemies.
I have nothing but admiration and gratitude for the men and women who put themselves in the line of fire to defend our country. And I acknowledge that it is sometimes necessary to go to war. But I think that we in America become obsessed with conflict, with winning, with the enemy. We dwell upon military might rather than the freedoms our military is supposed to safeguard for us.
“America the Beautiful,” on the other hand, dwells on the magnificence of the land in all its natural glory. We sing about “spacious skies,” amber waves of grain,” and “purple mountain majesties.” We ask God to “crown thy good with brotherhood” and “confirm thy soul in self-control, thy liberty in law.” Perhaps if we emphasized the grandeur of our physical environment, we would be more obsessed with protecting our land rather than destroying it. And if we prioritized the noble goals of brotherhood and the rule of law, our country would be the better for it.
If our national anthem represents what our country is all about, then maybe our emphasis on war and conquering should yield to an appreciation for the land that “pilgrim feet” trod to beat “a thoroughfare of freedom.”